President Trump’s new head of the United States Patent and Trademark Office, Andrei Iancu, recently noted that uncertainty about what kinds of innovation are patent-eligible is weakening investment, growth, and jobs in high tech industries:
I do worry that the current state of Section 101 in patentable subject matter weakens the robustness of our IP system in the affected areas. And if industry cannot predict in a relatively reliable way whether their investments will be protected from an intellectual property point of view I think that will result in less investment, less growth, fewer jobs created in the affected industries. So I do think it is critically important for our economy. And again whatever industry we’re talking about and whatever industry we want to grow it’s critically important to have a strong reliable and predictable intellectual property system.
Yesterday, two well respected and long-serving judges on the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals (the court designated to handle all patent appeals), Judges Lourie and Newman (with 66 years of experience hearing patent appeals on the Federal Circuit between them), echoed Director Iancu’s concerns. In a concurring opinion, they wrote separately to say that Congress needs to clarify the kinds of inventions that are patentable:
I concur in the court’s declining to rehear this case enbanc. There is plausibility to the panel holding that thereare fact issues potentially involved in this case concerningthe abstract idea exception to patent eligibility. And thepanel, and the court, are bound to follow the script thatthe Supreme Court has written for us in § 101 cases.
However, I believe the law needs clarification byhigher authority, perhaps by Congress, to work its wayout of what so many in the innovation field consider are§ 101 problems. Individual cases, whether heard by thiscourt or the Supreme Court, are imperfect vehicles forenunciating broad principles because they are limited tothe facts presented. Section 101 issues certainly requireattention beyond the power of this court.
Still, we are at an inflection point with respect to the patent system. As a nation, we cannot continue down the same path if we want to maintain our global economic leadership. And we will not continue down the same path. This administration has a mission to create sustained economic growth, and innovation and IP protection are key goals in support of that mission.
As an inventor, I have frequently spoken on the subject of innovation. One point I have repeatedly made is that it would be far better to have bad rules than to be unsure of what the rules are. Given the current state of confusion about which inventions are patent-eligible, it would be hard for even the most dysfunctional Congress to worsen the situation. The alarming uncertainty in the U.S. patent system seems to finally be getting the attention it badly needs.
While we await Congressional action that may or may not come, it is all the more critical that inventors turn to experienced patent lawyers capable of laying out the pros, cons, and unknowns about inventions.
Gary S. Shuster is an inventor and technology lawyer. He provides representation to clients in the development, licensing, sale and funding of new technologies and business enterprises, the protection and enforcement of intellectual property and trade secrets and the prosecution and defense of complex commercial and intellectual property litigation.
Established in 1994, Coleman & Horowitt is a state-wide law firm focused on delivering responsive and value driven service and preventive law. The firm represents businesses and their owners in matters involving transactions, litigation, agriculture and environmental regulation and litigation, intellectual property, real estate, estate planning and probate.
The Firm has been recognized as a “Top Law Firm” (Martindale Hubbell) and a “Go-To” Law Firm (Corporate Counsel). From six offices in California, and the Firm’s membership in Primerus, a national and international society of highly rated law firms (www.primerus.com), the Firm has helped individuals and businesses solve their most difficult legal problems. For more information, see www.ch-law.com and www.Primerus.com.
Disclaimer: This article is intended to provide the reader with general information regarding current legal issues. It is not to be construed as specific legal advice or as a substitute for the need to seek competent legal advice on specific legal matters. This publication is not meant to serve as a solicitation of business. To the extent that this may be considered as advertising, then it is expressly identified as such.
Search for:
Categories
- Agriculture (6)
- Announcements (14)
- Arbitration (1)
- banking (1)
- Billing (1)
- Business Litigation (12)
- business transaction (4)
- Business Transactions (4)
- Collection & Creditor Rights (7)
- Commercial Litigation (13)
- Construction (8)
- COVID-19 (6)
- Education (1)
- Entrepreneurship (2)
- Environmental law (67)
- Estate Planning (9)
- Financial (1)
- Insurance Liability (3)
- Intellectual Property law (71)
- Labor & Employment (22)
- Mediation (2)
- News (166)
- NFT (1)
- Personal Injury (1)
- Podcast (6)
- Real Estate (5)
- Real Estate Law (10)
- trademark (4)
- trial (3)
- Uncategorized (2)
- Webinar (2)
Tags
ab 617
ACEC
Agriculture
Air Quality
America Invents Act (AIA)
Bakersfield
business transactions
CARB
CEQA
CEQA Guidelines
Coleman & Horowitt
collections
Copyright
Coronavirus
covid-19
design patents
Estate Plan
Estate Planning
Family Trust
Fresno
groundwater
groundwater rights
insurance
Inventor
litigation
Living Trust
Los Angeles
Mediation
Newport Beach
Oehha
Patent
patent lawyers
Probate
Prop 65
realestate
real estate
SGMA
Sonora
Trademark
USPTO
Visalia
Water
water quality
Wetlands
will
Archives
.hidden_ar{display:none}
- August (1)
jQuery(document).ready(function(){
jQuery(“.toggle”).click(function(){
// jQuery(“.hidden_ar”).hide(“fast”);
var className = jQuery(this).attr(“data-toggle-class”);
jQuery(“.”+className).slideToggle();
jQuery( “.hidden_ar” ).each(function( index ) {
if (jQuery(“.”+className).attr(“data-toggle-class”)!=jQuery( this ).attr(“data-toggle-class”)) {
console.log( index );
jQuery(this).slideUp();
}
});
});
});
jQuery(document).ready(function(){
jQuery(“.toggle”).click(function(){
// jQuery(“.hidden_ar”).hide(“fast”);
var className = jQuery(this).attr(“data-toggle-class”);
jQuery(“.”+className).slideToggle();
jQuery( “.hidden_ar” ).each(function( index ) {
if (jQuery(“.”+className).attr(“data-toggle-class”)!=jQuery( this ).attr(“data-toggle-class”)) {
console.log( index );
jQuery(this).slideUp();
}
});
});
});